TL;DR

The typical bachelor's graduate owes federal loans equal to 56.6% of first-year earnings, in EDsmart Data's analysis of 23,734 College Scorecard programs. The lightest burden is in Engineering (33.8%); the heaviest is in Communications Technologies/Technicians and Support Services (114.1%).

Key Facts

  • Median bachelor's debt-to-earnings: 56.6% of first-year pay
  • Lowest-burden major: Systems Engineering (23.8%)
  • Highest-burden major: Behavioral Sciences (130.7%)
  • Majors where median debt exceeds a year of pay: 8 of 188

Download the data

Download CSV Download JSON

Downloads reflect the processed dataset used on this page.

Debt as a share of first-year earnings, by field of study

Where debt outruns pay

Our analysis finds graduates in Communications Technologies/Technicians and Support Services carry debt worth 114.1% of a year's pay, more than 237% heavier than in Engineering.

— Evidence from EDsmart Data analysis

Bachelor's programs only. Lowest and highest 10 field families with at least 15 reporting programs.

Debt-to-earnings ratio by field family (bachelor's)

Debt-to-earnings ratio by field family (bachelor's)
Field familyDebt as % of year-1 earningsMedian debtMedian year-1 earningsPrograms
Engineering33.8%$24,904$72,6901,648
Computer and Information Sciences and Support Services39.3%$26,000$66,2091,102
Transportation and Materials Moving40.1%$22,000$54,82754
Engineering/Engineering-Related Technologies/Technicians40.4%$26,875$66,749343
Mathematics and Statistics41.9%$21,488$53,132329
Health Professions and Related Programs47.1%$31,000$78,1652,293
Agricultural/Animal/Plant/Veterinary Science and Related Fields52.9%$21,500$40,194327
Business, Management, Marketing, and Related Support Services53.3%$26,000$52,7583,922
Physical Sciences54.8%$23,625$42,204384
Architecture and Related Services55.6%$26,000$46,954138
Social Sciences56.9%$22,907$37,7671,841
Area, Ethnic, Cultural, Gender, and Group Studies57.7%$19,000$31,955140
Education62.1%$26,000$41,7201,229
Legal Professions and Studies62.3%$24,753$39,55873
Multi/Interdisciplinary Studies62.7%$25,000$39,839513
Communication, Journalism, and Related Programs63.9%$24,208$36,6661,100
Foreign Languages, Literatures, and Linguistics65.5%$21,000$31,969293
Natural Resources and Conservation66.9%$22,692$34,000321
Homeland Security, Law Enforcement, Firefighting and Related Protective Services69.8%$26,000$37,792716
Public Administration and Social Service Professions70.7%$26,970$38,638519
Liberal Arts and Sciences, General Studies and Humanities71.5%$26,599$37,786427
History72.6%$23,100$31,852381
Biological and Biomedical Sciences73.6%$24,000$32,9251,348
Philosophy and Religious Studies73.8%$24,072$34,66694
Family and Consumer Sciences/Human Sciences74.0%$25,275$34,030325
Parks, Recreation, Leisure, Fitness, and Kinesiology75.8%$25,000$31,492620
Psychology77.2%$25,000$32,2761,072
English Language and Literature/Letters78.5%$24,822$29,848620
Theology and Religious Vocations78.6%$25,454$33,30891
Culinary, Entertainment, and Personal Services82.4%$27,000$32,77515
Visual and Performing Arts94.5%$25,988$25,3591,356
Communications Technologies/Technicians and Support Services114.1%$26,748$25,84867

Debt-to-earnings ratio for 188 bachelor's majors, lowest to highest

Majors (4-digit CIP) with at least 10 programs reporting both debt and earnings.

Debt-to-earnings ratio for 188 bachelor's majors, lowest to highest
MajorDebt as % of year-1 earningsMedian debtYear-1 earningsYear-5 earningsPrograms
Systems Engineering23.8%$19,500$81,785$108,02011
Fire Protection28.0%$21,248$81,637$87,49020
Computer Science29.4%$22,500$77,385$110,266317
Computer Engineering30.7%$24,337$81,123$110,493161
Manufacturing Engineering31.0%$21,457$69,520$91,73812
Nuclear Engineering31.2%$23,000$74,540$94,37210
Electrical, Electronics, and Communications Engineering31.3%$25,000$77,971$99,424242
Construction Engineering Technology/Technician31.9%$22,750$74,199$94,66038
Industrial Engineering32.0%$24,889$76,390$102,36589
Chemical Engineering32.6%$23,875$75,340$97,829152
Construction Engineering33.4%$26,698$80,936$102,18310
Construction Management33.9%$24,600$72,779$93,01651
Engineering, Other34.1%$22,875$74,204$94,29217
Statistics34.6%$20,150$59,718$92,38243
Mechanical Engineering34.7%$25,000$70,763$91,528316
Materials Engineering35.1%$23,125$74,496$89,57230
Agricultural Engineering35.3%$23,500$64,486$85,40421
Civil Engineering35.4%$25,000$69,424$85,902221
Engineering/Engineering-Related Technologies/Technicians, Other35.4%$25,000$70,620$86,20514
Aerospace, Aeronautical, and Astronautical/Space Engineering35.4%$26,000$75,036$97,91558
Insurance35.9%$23,016$64,131$94,22816
Engineering, General36.1%$26,113$68,331$88,67046
Applied Mathematics36.2%$19,000$61,741$90,03638
Architectural Engineering36.4%$25,880$76,272$97,09812
Biomedical/Medical Engineering36.6%$23,250$66,075$94,444115
Computer/Information Technology Administration and Management36.9%$26,917$66,588$78,42194
Engineering-Related Fields37.0%$26,404$71,117$90,24327
Industrial Production Technologies/Technicians37.1%$23,497$63,324$77,54746
Quality Control and Safety Technologies/Technicians37.3%$26,000$67,072$86,06719
General Sales, Merchandising and Related Marketing Operations37.4%$22,000$51,066$73,38926
Petroleum Engineering37.7%$24,638$68,913$100,79118
Finance and Financial Management Services38.2%$23,000$57,777$85,456413
Environmental/Environmental Health Engineering38.4%$24,350$64,453$80,25942
Computer and Information Sciences, General38.7%$25,250$67,315$92,993411
Business, Management, Marketing, and Related Support Services, Other39.0%$19,802$50,740$73,45728
Management Information Systems and Services39.2%$24,500$63,023$85,514142
Real Estate39.3%$21,032$55,257$85,27523
Information Science/Studies39.3%$26,000$66,209$92,982136
Management Sciences and Quantitative Methods39.7%$24,250$58,140$73,253122
Agricultural Business and Management39.8%$20,000$50,136$68,68768
Air Transportation40.1%$22,000$54,827$83,81148
Business/Managerial Economics40.1%$21,375$52,029$83,64572
Mechanical Engineering Related Technologies/Technicians40.7%$26,990$64,284$81,37450
International Business40.8%$23,472$51,843$69,65291
Electromechanical Technologies/Technicians41.5%$27,000$65,043$83,39922
Food Science and Technology42.1%$20,945$52,084$66,52723
Engineering Technologies/Technicians, General42.2%$26,325$62,089$84,65534
Allied Health Diagnostic, Intervention, and Treatment Professions42.2%$26,731$66,750$68,561178
Mathematics42.9%$21,750$49,919$73,553242
Clinical/Medical Laboratory Science/Research and Allied Professions43.2%$27,000$65,935$73,35481
Accounting and Related Services43.5%$25,299$55,203$72,738677
Economics43.6%$22,907$53,024$84,140336
Biotechnology43.8%$20,618$49,916$81,03817
Cognitive Science43.9%$17,481$39,839$78,26717
Homeland Security43.9%$23,250$51,200$68,14928
Dental Support Services and Allied Professions44.1%$25,880$59,772$63,44272
Plant Sciences44.2%$20,500$45,163$53,95841
Public Policy Analysis44.9%$22,341$49,685$67,94736
Homeland Security, Law Enforcement, Firefighting and Related Protective Services, Other47.1%$25,000$45,696$61,75011
Registered Nursing, Nursing Administration, Nursing Research and Clinical Nursing47.1%$38,145$83,188$92,768990
Public Administration48.2%$21,000$46,281$61,05043
Marketing49.3%$23,896$47,664$69,084482
Landscape Architecture49.3%$27,000$53,355$63,41611
Security Science and Technology50.3%$19,500$38,789$56,04637
Agriculture, General50.4%$20,000$39,438$52,29342
Physics50.7%$23,357$43,461$82,77570
Forestry52.0%$22,173$41,189$60,17027
Human Resources Management and Services52.1%$27,000$51,664$67,094160
International Relations and National Security Studies52.6%$21,977$43,249$67,400102
Sustainability Studies52.9%$19,500$37,223$62,84117
Architectural Sciences and Technology53.7%$29,000$50,115$66,27526
Chemistry54.9%$23,250$43,061$68,591194
Pharmacy, Pharmaceutical Sciences, and Administration54.9%$20,500$47,882$82,52312
Entrepreneurial and Small Business Operations55.0%$25,406$45,265$61,51349
Area Studies55.0%$19,000$35,304$62,04155
Architecture55.6%$26,000$46,347$67,43663
Science, Technology and Society55.6%$18,006$40,297$80,69910
Biochemistry, Biophysics and Molecular Biology55.6%$20,250$38,985$69,587126
Business Administration, Management and Operations56.3%$27,000$51,562$62,3441,122
Multi/Interdisciplinary Studies, Other56.8%$25,000$45,875$54,523187
Geography and Cartography56.9%$22,775$39,960$57,00282
Public Relations, Advertising, and Applied Communication57.1%$24,500$42,099$64,008174
City/Urban, Community, and Regional Planning57.5%$27,000$46,954$61,41115
Special Education and Teaching57.6%$26,878$45,167$49,952151
Ethnic, Cultural Minority, Gender, and Group Studies57.7%$19,000$31,140$55,20285
Agricultural Production Operations57.9%$22,123$35,167$49,63315
Microbiological Sciences and Immunology58.2%$20,500$37,610$65,14455
Computer Programming59.1%$28,000$50,242$79,50728
International/Globalization Studies59.1%$20,250$36,883$62,79377
Interior Architecture59.4%$27,000$45,345$59,00613
Romance Languages, Literatures, and Linguistics59.6%$21,250$33,705$55,893181
Research and Experimental Psychology60.1%$19,000$32,301$62,40184
Political Science and Government60.5%$22,375$37,009$67,019513
Geological and Earth Sciences/Geosciences60.8%$25,000$39,997$59,465100
Non-Professional Legal Studies60.9%$24,386$39,558$62,81738
Urban Studies/Affairs61.0%$23,000$40,294$60,70923
Animal Sciences61.3%$21,745$34,933$54,28781
Cell/Cellular Biology and Anatomical Sciences61.5%$22,000$36,532$70,18135
Teacher Education and Professional Development, Specific Subject Areas61.5%$25,523$42,589$51,417321
Hospitality Administration/Management61.7%$23,448$35,277$51,398133
Teacher Education and Professional Development, Specific Levels and Methods61.7%$26,000$41,595$46,217647
Apparel and Textiles61.9%$24,750$38,262$55,27951
Human Biology62.0%$14,500$31,891$79,09810
Criminology62.8%$23,887$37,108$54,589107
Social Sciences, Other63.0%$21,366$36,279$62,97529
Public Health63.9%$25,000$37,548$56,290211
Philosophy64.2%$20,000$32,749$55,12472
Journalism64.5%$24,208$36,468$58,392171
Genetics64.9%$21,216$31,800$68,30111
Communication and Media Studies65.2%$24,068$36,424$55,642598
Parks, Recreation, and Leisure Studies65.3%$22,500$34,742$50,74246
Education, General66.0%$27,000$41,421$47,04360
Natural Resources Conservation and Research66.2%$22,309$33,976$54,775224
Sociology66.2%$23,503$34,121$52,284399
Housing and Human Environments66.5%$25,683$38,637$51,75511
Communication, Journalism, and Related Programs, Other66.9%$25,479$34,432$62,02218
Multi-/Interdisciplinary Studies, General67.2%$25,000$35,476$50,44250
Education, Other67.6%$25,367$35,712$48,01621
Family and Consumer Economics and Related Studies68.2%$24,752$36,280$49,65616
Specialized Sales, Merchandising and Marketing Operations68.3%$26,000$36,625$57,47839
Allied Health and Medical Assisting Services68.3%$22,500$32,919$83,41310
Health Services/Allied Health/Health Sciences, General68.4%$23,875$35,746$56,837152
Community Organization and Advocacy69.1%$29,913$43,160$50,26519
Criminal Justice and Corrections69.8%$26,000$37,542$54,929620
Social Work70.1%$26,500$37,990$48,856334
Social Sciences, General70.3%$25,409$37,335$53,77671
Environmental/Natural Resources Management and Policy70.5%$25,998$39,422$51,45626
Liberal Arts and Sciences, General Studies and Humanities71.5%$26,599$37,786$49,421427
Linguistic, Comparative, and Related Language Studies and Services72.1%$19,899$27,629$48,75975
Health/Medical Preparatory Programs72.1%$25,993$34,923$59,58134
Mental and Social Health Services and Allied Professions72.3%$27,000$37,693$47,71646
History72.6%$23,100$31,852$50,950381
Physiology, Pathology and Related Sciences72.6%$23,125$29,884$67,87461
Rhetoric and Composition/Writing Studies72.8%$26,000$33,401$53,363112
Biological and Physical Sciences73.0%$26,000$35,639$66,38234
Parks, Recreation, and Leisure Facilities Management73.0%$25,000$31,873$50,48848
Biological and Biomedical Sciences, Other73.6%$26,000$35,324$80,06513
East Asian Languages, Literatures, and Linguistics74.0%$20,750$27,331$50,65115
Biology, General74.5%$24,161$32,940$63,464825
Neurobiology and Neurosciences74.9%$22,286$29,765$67,84890
Health Professions and Related Clinical Sciences, Other75.1%$26,000$35,973$60,57243
Family and Consumer Sciences/Human Sciences, General75.2%$25,125$32,008$46,14439
Nutrition Sciences75.5%$24,586$32,525$56,20549
Radio, Television, and Digital Communication75.7%$24,250$29,388$48,482138
Bible/Biblical Studies76.0%$24,500$35,114$42,21531
American Sign Language76.0%$25,287$33,775$46,83114
Sports, Kinesiology, and Physical Education/Fitness76.3%$25,000$31,165$56,525524
Human Development, Family Studies, and Related Services76.7%$26,000$34,030$44,784165
Natural Sciences77.3%$26,000$28,107$64,44210
Legal Support Services77.6%$27,750$41,375$47,68023
Theological and Ministerial Studies77.9%$23,774$32,202$48,54124
Communication Disorders Sciences and Services78.1%$21,000$26,286$59,735104
Psychology, General78.3%$25,000$32,276$51,142932
English Language and Literature, General78.6%$24,529$29,848$48,554484
Electrical/Electronic Engineering Technologies/Technicians78.7%$53,062$67,395$85,00537
Sociology and Anthropology78.8%$26,500$29,054$43,80910
Design and Applied Arts79.2%$26,899$32,665$53,422259
Computer Systems Networking and Telecommunications79.3%$48,014$60,540$73,31536
Anthropology79.4%$22,523$28,314$47,132168
Business/Corporate Communications80.1%$26,000$32,445$56,83723
Health and Medical Administrative Services80.3%$38,210$44,580$51,707256
Ecology, Evolution, Systematics, and Population Biology80.6%$23,461$29,074$45,40758
Rehabilitation and Therapeutic Professions81.4%$27,000$33,153$50,80157
Pastoral Counseling and Specialized Ministries81.7%$26,750$34,083$40,55616
Computer Software and Media Applications82.5%$27,000$34,166$44,88453
Foods, Nutrition, and Related Services82.9%$27,000$32,586$41,94335
Clinical, Counseling and Applied Psychology84.6%$27,000$35,065$51,98852
Zoology/Animal Biology86.0%$25,000$29,303$52,43450
Dietetics and Clinical Nutrition Services87.0%$25,798$36,834$53,14635
Wildlife and Wildlands Science and Management87.3%$25,000$28,178$44,77834
Computer Systems Analysis88.8%$46,000$51,805$74,58519
Music91.6%$26,000$26,011$40,816217
Arts, Entertainment, and Media Management92.2%$25,468$28,449$40,06139
Fine and Studio Arts94.7%$25,293$24,419$42,040363
Religion/Religious Studies94.7%$36,495$38,540$49,60321
Religious Education95.1%$35,436$35,803$42,16912
Educational Administration and Supervision95.2%$35,697$37,480$42,81015
Human Services, General95.6%$35,750$37,571$46,00480
Film/Video and Photographic Arts95.7%$25,000$24,078$42,807129
Visual and Performing Arts, General99.2%$26,000$25,702$41,22654
Business/Commerce, General102.0%$56,517$55,431$63,772250
English Language and Literature/Letters, Other105.2%$25,500$24,239$51,37216
Graphic Communications110.5%$26,748$25,358$49,98349
Audiovisual Communications Technologies/Technicians110.7%$27,000$29,736$34,94014
Computer Engineering Technologies/Technicians113.5%$55,425$48,829$81,09022
Drama/Theatre Arts and Stagecraft114.8%$25,000$20,532$33,461234
Dance117.4%$25,000$21,877$33,04151
Behavioral Sciences130.7%$49,770$37,661$43,71214

What the data shows

A common rule of thumb says total student debt should not exceed your first-year salary. By that yardstick, 8 of the 188 majors we measured fail at the median, meaning the typical graduate owes more than a full year of pay.

Systems Engineering has the lightest burden (23.8%: $19,500 of debt against $81,785 in first-year pay). Behavioral Sciences has the heaviest (130.7%).

Debt is driven mostly by where you enroll and how much aid you get, while earnings are driven mostly by the field. That is why the same major can look very different school to school; check the program-level numbers on individual school pages before you borrow.

Methodology

Program figures come from the College Scorecard field-of-study file: one record per institution × 4-digit CIP code × credential level. Earnings are median annual earnings of federal-aid recipients who completed the program and were working and not enrolled, measured 1, 4, and 5 years after completion (in the dollar year of the Scorecard release). Debt is the median federal loan balance (Stafford and Grad PLUS) at completion; private loans and Parent PLUS are excluded. Programs with too few graduates are suppressed by the Department of Education and drop out of each column.

The debt-to-earnings ratio for each program is median federal debt at completion divided by median earnings one year after completion, shown as a percentage. Field and family figures are the median program ratio weighted by the number of borrowers.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good debt-to-earnings ratio for a college major?

Debt at or below first-year earnings (100%) is a common benchmark. The typical bachelor's program sits at 56.6%, based on College Scorecard program data.

Which majors have the lowest debt compared with earnings?

Systems Engineering, Fire Protection, and Computer Science have the lowest ratios among majors with at least 10 reporting programs (23.8%, 28.0%, and 29.4%).

Which majors have the highest debt compared with earnings?

Behavioral Sciences (130.7%) and Dance (117.4%) have the heaviest burdens at the median.

Does this include private student loans?

No. College Scorecard reports federal loans only (Direct Stafford and Grad PLUS). Private loans and Parent PLUS loans are not included, so total borrowing can be higher.

Data sources

  • U.S. Department of Education, College Scorecard institution and field-of-study files (latest release in our extract)