TL;DR

The typical bachelor's graduate owes federal loans equal to 45.7% of first-year earnings, in EDsmart Data's analysis of 21,243 College Scorecard programs. The lightest burden is in Transportation and Materials Moving (28.8%); the heaviest is in Communications Technologies/Technicians and Support Services (96.0%).

Key Facts

  • Median bachelor's debt-to-earnings: 45.7% of first-year pay
  • Lowest-burden major: Fire Protection (15.9%)
  • Highest-burden major: Audiovisual Communications Technologies/Technicians (105.2%)
  • Majors where median debt exceeds a year of pay: 3 of 174

Download the data

Download CSV Download JSON

Downloads reflect the processed dataset used on this page.

Debt as a share of first-year earnings, by field of study

Where debt outruns pay

Our analysis finds graduates in Communications Technologies/Technicians and Support Services carry debt worth 96.0% of a year's pay, more than 233% heavier than in Transportation and Materials Moving.

— Evidence from EDsmart Data analysis

Bachelor's programs only. Lowest and highest 10 field families with at least 15 reporting programs.

Debt-to-earnings ratio by field family (bachelor's)

Debt-to-earnings ratio by field family (bachelor's)
Field familyDebt as % of year-1 earningsMedian debtMedian year-1 earningsPrograms
Transportation and Materials Moving28.8%$18,781$64,22066
Engineering29.3%$22,500$76,9301,502
Mathematics and Statistics31.4%$19,500$60,621254
Computer and Information Sciences and Support Services32.6%$23,250$69,9911,059
Engineering/Engineering-Related Technologies/Technicians32.6%$24,375$71,926274
Area, Ethnic, Cultural, Gender, and Group Studies43.2%$16,700$40,519100
Physical Sciences43.3%$20,500$48,360270
Business, Management, Marketing, and Related Support Services43.8%$24,473$56,3023,560
Social Sciences43.9%$20,012$44,2061,498
Architecture and Related Services44.2%$24,251$55,583121
Health Professions and Related Programs45.7%$36,000$86,8682,194
Agricultural/Animal/Plant/Veterinary Science and Related Fields46.7%$20,125$42,612270
Communication, Journalism, and Related Programs47.8%$21,000$44,213925
Foreign Languages, Literatures, and Linguistics50.3%$19,500$38,320180
Multi/Interdisciplinary Studies52.1%$23,576$44,956452
Legal Professions and Studies52.4%$22,883$43,55159
Natural Resources and Conservation52.4%$20,500$40,695314
History54.8%$21,382$38,779317
Education55.0%$23,916$44,6611,141
Philosophy and Religious Studies56.7%$20,538$41,32467
Biological and Biomedical Sciences57.3%$21,492$37,7291,280
Liberal Arts and Sciences, General Studies and Humanities57.6%$25,917$43,113379
Family and Consumer Sciences/Human Sciences57.7%$23,250$39,329277
English Language and Literature/Letters57.7%$21,844$36,127491
Parks, Recreation, Leisure, Fitness, and Kinesiology59.2%$23,149$38,359587
Public Administration and Social Service Professions59.5%$25,000$42,555460
Homeland Security, Law Enforcement, Firefighting and Related Protective Services60.1%$25,000$43,044695
Psychology61.2%$23,000$37,5931,066
Theology and Religious Vocations67.8%$24,734$37,89459
Visual and Performing Arts69.5%$24,059$32,9571,211
Communications Technologies/Technicians and Support Services96.0%$26,000$29,89567

Debt-to-earnings ratio for 174 bachelor's majors, lowest to highest

Majors (4-digit CIP) with at least 10 programs reporting both debt and earnings.

Debt-to-earnings ratio for 174 bachelor's majors, lowest to highest
MajorDebt as % of year-1 earningsMedian debtYear-1 earningsYear-5 earningsPrograms
Fire Protection15.9%$14,907$82,625$93,98016
Statistics22.2%$17,629$70,309$100,01744
Computer Science25.5%$19,588$82,449$120,363323
Industrial Engineering26.1%$20,627$79,613$105,21674
Construction Engineering26.4%$21,500$79,703$108,79511
Construction Engineering Technology/Technician26.4%$21,250$79,485$104,01139
Electrical, Electronics, and Communications Engineering26.9%$22,500$82,641$105,202205
Intelligence, Command Control and Information Operations27.0%$19,500$63,584$84,04110
Materials Engineering27.1%$20,500$77,737$94,31517
Chemical Engineering27.4%$21,750$80,878$102,660139
Electrical/Electronic Engineering Technologies/Technicians27.6%$22,824$78,810$94,17614
Agricultural Engineering28.1%$22,153$71,101$92,01416
Computer Engineering28.2%$22,946$85,528$120,984152
Computer and Information Sciences, General28.5%$22,985$73,113$99,682376
Construction Management29.2%$21,500$74,803$99,43953
Mechanical Engineering29.6%$22,454$75,796$95,975316
Air Transportation29.7%$18,500$64,220$99,66059
Industrial Production Technologies/Technicians29.8%$22,000$70,751$85,82532
General Sales, Merchandising and Related Marketing Operations29.9%$19,500$57,659$81,60920
Biomedical/Medical Engineering29.9%$21,500$72,751$100,258110
Aerospace, Aeronautical, and Astronautical/Space Engineering30.3%$23,500$78,794$101,72560
Insurance30.3%$19,500$70,256$97,31816
Real Estate30.3%$20,000$64,646$86,15025
Applied Mathematics31.0%$20,500$63,684$99,03931
Cognitive Science31.0%$14,456$46,650$85,57516
Mechanical Engineering Related Technologies/Technicians31.3%$23,000$71,149$85,79749
Management Sciences and Quantitative Methods31.5%$21,000$63,116$83,075126
Engineering-Related Fields31.5%$23,250$74,839$96,47321
Civil Engineering31.8%$23,250$72,499$90,287215
Management Information Systems and Services31.9%$20,787$68,559$95,137104
Economics31.9%$19,500$60,469$88,644261
Biotechnology32.2%$16,750$51,190$90,17014
Finance and Financial Management Services32.7%$20,500$63,036$91,065397
Food Science and Technology33.4%$19,500$56,486$82,78810
Engineering, General33.5%$25,350$74,573$91,59749
Mathematics33.9%$19,500$54,997$81,490177
Environmental/Environmental Health Engineering33.9%$22,293$68,424$84,58834
Dental Support Services and Allied Professions34.1%$23,715$70,434$69,72968
Area Studies34.4%$15,616$43,277$69,02432
Business, Management, Marketing, and Related Support Services, Other34.4%$18,500$53,815$76,07918
Quality Control and Safety Technologies/Technicians34.5%$26,000$75,355$91,01518
Computer Programming34.9%$25,000$68,479$85,84318
Architectural Engineering35.0%$25,314$78,742$97,42814
Allied Health Diagnostic, Intervention, and Treatment Professions35.4%$25,537$71,252$77,913136
Business/Managerial Economics35.4%$20,074$57,980$86,17848
Computer/Information Technology Administration and Management35.4%$26,000$71,646$96,720122
Agricultural Business and Management35.5%$18,950$54,078$73,93158
International Business36.1%$21,437$55,318$78,91756
Physics36.6%$20,199$53,377$89,72949
Information Science/Studies36.6%$25,000$68,240$101,568119
Electromechanical Technologies/Technicians36.7%$26,250$71,604$78,18012
Public Administration37.0%$19,103$50,714$65,44032
Engineering Technologies/Technicians, General37.8%$24,464$67,295$84,25633
Homeland Security38.4%$20,750$62,578$74,97230
Public Policy Analysis38.8%$19,737$52,170$72,65832
Accounting and Related Services39.1%$23,384$60,907$80,625562
International Relations and National Security Studies39.4%$19,750$47,319$74,50780
Clinical/Medical Laboratory Science/Research and Allied Professions39.6%$25,250$69,170$78,64869
Marketing40.2%$21,500$54,296$75,817452
Human Resources Management and Services40.6%$25,250$56,434$74,621135
International/Globalization Studies40.7%$18,578$45,705$65,85350
Chemistry40.7%$19,875$48,360$72,093143
Entrepreneurial and Small Business Operations41.9%$22,842$50,499$67,55453
Plant Sciences42.1%$20,500$45,006$61,57032
Education, General42.1%$20,500$43,747$51,19058
Homeland Security, Law Enforcement, Firefighting and Related Protective Services, Other42.5%$22,500$52,084$70,47511
Forestry43.1%$20,500$46,942$60,86324
Cell/Cellular Biology and Anatomical Sciences43.4%$18,527$44,322$74,59030
Microbiological Sciences and Immunology43.6%$18,607$42,913$71,44139
Urban Studies/Affairs43.7%$21,311$44,690$69,09816
City/Urban, Community, and Regional Planning44.0%$24,251$55,101$74,00210
Business Administration, Management and Operations44.0%$24,975$56,241$68,2741,118
Ethnic, Cultural Minority, Gender, and Group Studies44.2%$17,000$40,138$57,84068
Hospitality Administration/Management44.6%$20,500$46,497$60,19493
Romance Languages, Literatures, and Linguistics44.6%$19,500$40,253$60,587103
Public Relations, Advertising, and Applied Communication44.7%$21,822$49,640$73,759136
Pharmacy, Pharmaceutical Sciences, and Administration44.9%$25,000$60,086$93,64413
Interior Architecture45.1%$24,984$49,575$65,19512
Specialized Sales, Merchandising and Marketing Operations45.2%$24,335$48,517$62,61724
Sustainability Studies45.5%$20,829$44,079$62,34921
Architecture45.6%$22,500$56,744$69,05449
Registered Nursing, Nursing Administration, Nursing Research and Clinical Nursing45.7%$41,125$89,974$98,387988
Geography and Cartography45.9%$21,250$46,974$64,74141
Agriculture, General46.1%$20,500$44,432$57,02231
Architectural Sciences and Technology46.4%$26,000$58,424$76,25634
Biochemistry, Biophysics and Molecular Biology46.6%$20,250$44,113$72,234110
Philosophy46.8%$19,535$41,023$67,36058
Non-Professional Legal Studies47.0%$22,883$43,920$65,62632
Political Science and Government47.1%$20,000$44,063$71,187461
Genetics47.3%$19,500$42,109$69,33411
Social Sciences, Other47.4%$20,672$43,588$67,74124
Journalism47.7%$20,628$43,348$63,023145
Communication and Media Studies47.9%$20,500$44,144$61,083510
Sociology48.5%$20,500$40,801$57,411321
Geological and Earth Sciences/Geosciences49.7%$22,000$45,317$65,03557
Human Biology50.9%$15,500$35,103$82,46410
Natural Resources Conservation and Research51.1%$19,500$41,037$60,453224
Apparel and Textiles51.1%$22,915$44,580$65,27743
Teacher Education and Professional Development, Specific Subject Areas51.2%$22,931$45,895$54,754281
Research and Experimental Psychology51.4%$19,500$37,249$60,96999
Education, Other51.4%$21,760$42,331$55,65819
Security Science and Technology51.9%$25,000$46,138$61,80749
Behavioral Sciences52.1%$20,750$38,662$49,74813
Radio, Television, and Digital Communication52.2%$22,624$39,256$55,954118
Linguistic, Comparative, and Related Language Studies and Services52.4%$19,500$32,879$56,16057
Parks, Recreation, and Leisure Studies52.4%$21,236$40,216$59,13042
Multi/Interdisciplinary Studies, Other52.7%$23,973$48,254$57,458150
Animal Sciences52.9%$20,500$38,523$58,11579
Environmental/Natural Resources Management and Policy53.1%$23,840$42,930$56,06627
Criminology53.4%$21,562$42,114$60,473113
Social Sciences, General53.7%$25,000$44,974$59,62052
Public Health54.1%$22,154$43,165$62,420208
Multi-/Interdisciplinary Studies, General54.3%$22,500$42,320$53,64366
Special Education and Teaching54.4%$25,000$47,786$51,906129
Family and Consumer Economics and Related Studies54.5%$22,498$41,245$54,10713
Health Services/Allied Health/Health Sciences, General54.5%$21,500$41,096$67,041155
Family and Consumer Sciences/Human Sciences, General54.8%$21,217$38,145$53,15226
History54.8%$21,382$38,779$55,339317
Health/Medical Preparatory Programs55.3%$22,681$39,127$64,65029
Health Professions and Related Clinical Sciences, Other55.6%$23,550$42,610$67,60743
Teacher Education and Professional Development, Specific Levels and Methods55.7%$24,295$44,402$48,310630
Parks, Recreation, and Leisure Facilities Management56.2%$25,000$43,044$57,30337
Neurobiology and Neurosciences56.3%$20,500$37,260$70,226103
English Language and Literature/Letters, Other56.5%$21,569$32,549$47,04512
Biology, General57.0%$21,500$37,351$67,462783
English Language and Literature, General57.4%$20,833$36,076$51,729399
Nutrition Sciences57.4%$20,343$36,414$63,93641
Liberal Arts and Sciences, General Studies and Humanities57.6%$25,917$43,113$56,190379
Housing and Human Environments57.6%$27,000$46,844$57,22910
Social Work58.0%$24,250$41,622$53,281306
Physiology, Pathology and Related Sciences58.2%$20,500$35,883$68,88664
Biological and Biomedical Sciences, Other58.6%$26,000$44,357$84,90015
Arts, Entertainment, and Media Management58.8%$23,125$38,224$52,81340
Veterinary/Animal Health Technologies/Technicians59.2%$23,125$38,955$43,10911
Sports, Kinesiology, and Physical Education/Fitness59.8%$23,149$37,878$60,523506
Criminal Justice and Corrections60.1%$25,000$42,494$58,618589
Ecology, Evolution, Systematics, and Population Biology60.9%$20,500$34,226$52,98353
Biological and Physical Sciences61.6%$25,125$40,786$78,28733
Human Development, Family Studies, and Related Services61.8%$24,500$38,150$49,623156
Wildlife and Wildlands Science and Management62.5%$22,187$33,653$48,98131
Psychology, General63.0%$23,250$37,593$54,626908
Theological and Ministerial Studies63.1%$23,900$37,894$46,84714
Design and Applied Arts63.3%$25,125$40,444$58,959245
Rhetoric and Composition/Writing Studies63.6%$23,250$38,852$57,74972
Zoology/Animal Biology63.8%$23,500$35,530$52,08449
Communication Disorders Sciences and Services64.0%$21,500$33,606$61,941112
Rehabilitation and Therapeutic Professions65.1%$25,000$38,413$53,91748
Bible/Biblical Studies65.3%$25,819$38,708$48,57621
Anthropology66.2%$21,500$34,316$52,399121
Foods, Nutrition, and Related Services66.6%$28,000$42,057$50,84021
Business/Corporate Communications68.1%$27,000$39,635$60,49918
Computer Software and Media Applications68.2%$27,000$41,435$47,78050
Communication, Journalism, and Related Programs, Other69.7%$24,250$38,911$68,01714
Dietetics and Clinical Nutrition Services69.7%$26,000$38,924$60,64532
Computer Engineering Technologies/Technicians69.7%$41,311$65,931$84,01120
Health and Medical Administrative Services69.9%$35,796$51,349$59,205229
Fine and Studio Arts70.2%$23,250$30,948$46,080332
Music71.2%$25,000$34,293$45,493180
Film/Video and Photographic Arts71.3%$23,250$30,998$49,650131
Legal Support Services72.5%$30,006$42,476$50,89516
Pastoral Counseling and Specialized Ministries73.0%$24,177$33,735$43,09315
Drama/Theatre Arts and Stagecraft74.4%$23,250$30,064$44,873183
Human Services, General75.4%$28,141$42,597$50,30170
Visual and Performing Arts, General75.8%$23,250$31,197$47,30761
Mental and Social Health Services and Allied Professions76.2%$33,002$40,244$55,05439
Computer Systems Analysis77.6%$47,695$61,471$77,83817
Computer Systems Networking and Telecommunications79.9%$51,954$65,000$78,37030
Clinical, Counseling and Applied Psychology83.3%$30,508$41,272$57,08255
Dance87.3%$25,000$28,929$44,19136
Graphic Communications96.1%$26,000$28,397$49,31951
Business/Commerce, General98.3%$55,362$56,302$65,700240
Community Organization and Advocacy104.5%$43,834$46,881$54,30914
Educational Administration and Supervision105.0%$47,389$45,145$46,67515
Audiovisual Communications Technologies/Technicians105.2%$40,958$38,520$47,55612

What the data shows

A common rule of thumb says total student debt should not exceed your first-year salary. By that yardstick, 3 of the 174 majors we measured fail at the median, meaning the typical graduate owes more than a full year of pay.

Fire Protection has the lightest burden (15.9%: $14,907 of debt against $82,625 in first-year pay). Audiovisual Communications Technologies/Technicians has the heaviest (105.2%).

Debt is driven mostly by where you enroll and how much aid you get, while earnings are driven mostly by the field. That is why the same major can look very different school to school; check the program-level numbers on individual school pages before you borrow.

Methodology

Program figures come from the College Scorecard field-of-study file: one record per institution × 4-digit CIP code × credential level. Earnings are median annual earnings of federal-aid recipients who completed the program and were working and not enrolled, measured 1, 4, and 5 years after completion (in the dollar year of the Scorecard release). Debt is the median federal loan balance (Stafford and Grad PLUS) at completion; private loans and Parent PLUS are excluded. Programs with too few graduates are suppressed by the Department of Education and drop out of each column.

The debt-to-earnings ratio for each program is median federal debt at completion divided by median earnings one year after completion, shown as a percentage. Field and family figures are the median program ratio weighted by the number of borrowers.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good debt-to-earnings ratio for a college major?

Debt at or below first-year earnings (100%) is a common benchmark. The typical bachelor's program sits at 45.7%, based on College Scorecard program data.

Which majors have the lowest debt compared with earnings?

Fire Protection, Statistics, and Computer Science have the lowest ratios among majors with at least 10 reporting programs (15.9%, 22.2%, and 25.5%).

Which majors have the highest debt compared with earnings?

Audiovisual Communications Technologies/Technicians (105.2%) and Educational Administration and Supervision (105.0%) have the heaviest burdens at the median.

Does this include private student loans?

No. College Scorecard reports federal loans only (Direct Stafford and Grad PLUS). Private loans and Parent PLUS loans are not included, so total borrowing can be higher.

Data sources

  • U.S. Department of Education, College Scorecard institution and field-of-study files (latest release in our extract)